What to Do When Shopify Flags an Order as High Risk
Who this is for
Ops, support, and fraud reviewers deciding whether to ship orders flagged by Shopify fraud analysis.
When Shopify marks an order high risk, its fraud analysis found indicators commonly associated with fraudulent orders — for example mismatched billing and shipping details, failed card attempts, or a proxy IP. It's a recommendation, not a block: the order is still paid and will ship unless you act. The safe default is to hold fulfilment, review the indicators, and cancel and refund if fraud looks likely. Shipping a fraudulent order usually means losing the goods, the revenue, and a chargeback fee.
When to use this
- An order shows 'High risk' or a 'Cancel order' recommendation.
- Chargebacks traced back to orders you could have caught.
- You're writing a fraud review SOP for the team.
- Order volume spikes during a sale and risk flags increase.
Step-by-step workflow
- 1
Hold fulfilment
Stop automatic fulfilment or 3PL routing for high-risk orders until reviewed.
- 2
Review the indicators
Read the fraud analysis details: address match, card attempts, IP location, and customer history.
- 3
Verify when the signals are mixed
Contact the customer through details on file, not those in a suspicious order. Don't ask for card photos.
- 4
Cancel and refund when fraud is likely
Cancel with reason 'fraud', refund, and restock. Refunding first avoids a chargeback on a card the real owner disputes.
- 5
Record the outcome
Tag the order with the decision so you can see your false-positive rate over time.
Frequently asked questions
Does Shopify cancel high-risk orders automatically?
Not by default. It flags them and recommends an action; you or a fraud app decide.
Should I ship a high-risk order?
Only after review. Many high-risk orders are legitimate, but shipping one that isn't usually leads to a chargeback you'll lose.
What's the difference between medium and high risk?
Medium means some indicators are present; high means several strong ones. Review both, but treat high as 'hold until cleared'.
Related resources and tools
- Shopify chargeback evidence checklist
- How to cancel an order in Shopify
- Shopify return fraud checklist
- How to Change a Shipping Address on a Shopify Order
- How to Archive Orders in Shopify
- How to Create a Draft Order in Shopify
- How to Partially Fulfill an Order in Shopify
- How to Issue a Partial Refund in Shopify
- Can You Edit a Shopify Order After Payment?